Almost every local business gets its new customers the same way now: someone nearby types what they need into Google — “plumber near me”, “dog groomer Exmouth”, “best breakfast Totnes” — and picks from the first few results. If you are in those results, you get the chance. If not, a competitor does.
The encouraging truth is that local search is winnable for small businesses. Google wants to show the genuinely best local option, and most of your competitors are doing this work badly or not at all. Here is the work, in priority order.
Understand what you are competing for
A local search result has two parts. The map pack — usually three businesses shown with stars, photos and directions — is driven by your Google Business Profile: its completeness, proximity to the searcher, categories, reviews and activity. The organic results below are driven by your website: content, structure, speed and relevance.
Most clicks for “near me” style searches go to the map pack; more considered searches (“kitchen fitter Devon reviews”) spread across both. You want presence in both, and helpfully, the work reinforces itself — the profile and the website each make the other stronger.
First: claim and complete your Google Business Profile
This is the highest-return hour a local business can spend on marketing. Claim the profile, verify it, and complete everything: precise categories (the primary category matters enormously), services, service area, hours including holidays, photos of real work and premises, and a plain description of what you do and where.
Then keep it alive — occasional posts, new photos, answered questions. Google visibly favours active profiles, and dormant ones drift down the map. Our Google Business Profile guide covers this step by step.
Second: reviews, asked for properly
Reviews are a major map-pack factor and the deciding factor for many customers. The strategy is simple and must be honest: ask every satisfied customer, at the moment of satisfaction, with a direct link that makes it a thirty-second job. A card with a QR code, a follow-up text, a line in your invoice email — pick what fits your business and make it routine.
Respond to reviews, including imperfect ones, briefly and graciously. Never buy reviews, never fake them, never review-gate (screening out unhappy customers before they reach Google) — all three violate Google’s policies and the penalty is worse than a mediocre rating.
Third: a website that confirms what the profile claims
When Google — or a cautious customer — checks your profile against your website, everything should match and reinforce: same business name, same area, same services described in more depth. A profile pointing at a thin, slow or generic website underperforms; one backed by a proper site rises.
The essentials: a page for each main service using the words customers search with; your location and service area stated naturally; fast loading on mobile; unique page titles and descriptions; and schema markup so machines understand what you are. This is standard in every website we build.
Fourth: content that answers real local questions
Beyond service pages, genuinely useful content wins the searches that big competitors ignore: “how much does a bathroom refit cost”, “dog friendly cafés near Dartmouth”, “do I need planning permission for a garden room”. One good page answering a real question your customers ask is worth more than ten pages of keyword filler.
Write what you already say on the phone every week. That knowledge is your SEO advantage over any national chain.
Fifth: consistency everywhere else
Your business name, address (or service area) and phone number should be identical everywhere they appear — website, profile, Facebook, directories. Inconsistencies erode Google’s confidence in your listing. This is dull, one-off work that quietly pays for years.
Measure what matters
You do not need dashboards — three numbers tell the story: how people find your profile (Google Business Profile insights), what your website visitors do (any basic analytics), and where enquiries actually come from (just ask “how did you find us?” and keep a tally). Those three reveal whether the work above is converting, and where the next effort should go.
If you would rather someone did all of this for you — audit, fixes, profile, content — that is precisely our SEO Devon service, and it starts with a free review of where you stand.
Want a second opinion on your website?
Request a free website review and we will tell you exactly what we would improve, and why.